Hayley

Hayley

  • Art Blog
brevoortformspring.tumblr.com The problem with diversity.

brevoortformspring:

“It’s always funny to see people hiding behind an anonymous tag daring people to face them. Take off your sheet, step into the light, and we can have a conversation. Otherwise, you can do like the other lot.”

Tom Brevoort, 2014


My name is Daniel Tonner.

I’m 27 years old. I live in Bremen,…

Okay, here’s the problem with the “just create new characters” argument:

There are dynasties within the comic world, held by a few characters and their publishing titles. Superman, Spiderman, Batman, Captain America, etc. are powerful names. They carry a lot of meaning. Creating new characters of color is a good idea, but these characters will not have the gravity of dynasty titles. They are easily overlooked and may not get the publicity they really need to make a difference.

To a young black man, seeing a black boy take the mantle of Spiderman - a character everyone likes, that has movie franchises, products easily bought, and a legion of other young fan boys and men - means more than you could ever realize. It’s a visual acceptance into a massive international community.

On another note, I saw someone make a very good point in the comments: you see little to no uproar regarding Doc-Oc becoming Peter Parker. Why is this alright, but Miles Morales is crossing the line?

He makes a lot of other very good points, about the lack of actual diversity in the diversity pushes within the industry. He also makes a lot of good points about very harmful misogyny still going on. I’m just very disappointed it was accompanied by other, misguided vitriol.

Part of sharing the spotlight and having true diversity within comics is going to be losing some real estate for white people. That’s an immutable fact. Accept it with grace and realize you’re not really “losing” anything at all.

8 years ago
Reblogged from New Brevoort Formspring
139 notes
  1. absolutehotsister reblogged this from brevoortformspring
  2. xxcarnariumxx liked this
  3. absolutehotsister liked this
  4. delitealex-blog liked this
  5. asiankungfu reblogged this from brevoortformspring
  6. ponyofthekseag liked this
  7. siku-ulva reblogged this from brevoortformspring and added:
    Okay, here’s the problem with the “just create new characters” argument: There are dynasties within the comic world,...
  8. arcadequartermaster liked this
  9. strangenessinajar liked this
  10. deathcubek liked this
  11. tincascade liked this
  12. oldnerdybasterd liked this
  13. aureliusambrosius reblogged this from brevoortformspring
  14. aureliusambrosius liked this
  15. evianacid reblogged this from brevoortformspring and added:
    Hi, Mr. Tonner. You say a lot of things here that I’m not sure… well. I think you ‘do’ have a few points here, but most...
  16. connerinlove liked this
  17. notsunami-blog liked this
  18. heli-pilot-landos-blog liked this
  19. thelectricninja liked this
  20. toocooltoknowhowtocaretobecool liked this
  21. aleksandersamuel liked this
  22. elsuperfuzz liked this
  23. lerri000 reblogged this from brevoortformspring and added:
    this was almost smart till you started talking about misogyny. Hey what about all those poor men gettin beaten since the...
  24. boogiethrillkill-blog reblogged this from brevoortformspring
  25. sugarcandybullet liked this
  26. pr1ncessprivilege liked this
  27. dandandandandandandandandandan liked this
  28. reynarddegoupil reblogged this from brevoortformspring
  29. reynarddegoupil liked this
  30. tonytylerdraws reblogged this from brevoortformspring and added:
    Hey D. I’m Africian American. And I think Marvel an DC are doing diversity right. I applaud you for coming out behind...
  31. lollipopmelons liked this
  32. aranaescarlata1888 reblogged this from brevoortformspring and added:
    This resonated with me so much! As a male of Punjabi origin, I’ve always been told that I couldn’t be Spidey or other...
  33. savealltheanswers-blog reblogged this from brevoortformspring and added:
    haha.
  34. savealltheanswers-blog liked this
  35. boogiethrillkill-blog liked this
  36. blacklungdisease liked this
  37. cowabunga-brah liked this
  38. crookedfeet liked this
  39. gigvigilance-cassettecollector liked this
  40. flailingpyro liked this
  41. kchgardens liked this
  42. brevoortformspring posted this
  43. Show more notesLoading...
© Hayley 2011–2023
Hipster Tumblr Theme by Precrafted